Major Victory for Wild Horses: Federal Appeals Court Dismisses Wyoming's Anti-Mustang Lawsuit

Precedential Decision Has Implications Across the West

DENVER, CO (October 11, 2016) - Today, the U.S. Court of Appeals Tenth Circuit upheld a lower court’sdismissalof a lawsuit filed by the State of Wyoming against the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) seeking the removal of hundreds of wild horses from public lands across the state. The American Wild Horse Conservation (formerly American Wild Horse Preservation Campaign) (AWHC),The Cloud Foundation,Return to Freedom, and wild horse photographersCarol WalkerandKimerlee Curylwere granted the right to intervene in the case and filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit against theBLM.

At issue in the case, first filed in 2014, were wild horses in the Antelope Hills, Crooks Mountain, Green Mountain, Lost Creek, Stewart Creek, Fifteenmile, and Little ColoradoHerd Management Areas(HMAs) in Wyoming.

The Tenth Circuitheld, “We reject the State’s arguments… the [Wild Horse] Act does not define the phrase 'appropriate management level' and thus does not equate it with any requirement to remove excess animals from a particular HMA… theBLMis under no statutory duty to remove animals from the seven HMAs at issue.”

“This is a major precedential victory that will have important implications for federal wild horsepolicyfor decades to come,” said Bill Eubanks of the public interest law firmMeyer, Glitzenstein and Eubanks, which represented the intervenors in this case.

“The appellate court has clearly affirmed two important issues – first that wild horse populations in excess of theBLM’s arbitrarily established ‘appropriate’ management levels do not equate with overpopulation, and second that theBLMis not required to remove wild horses from the range even if it determines an overpopulation exists,” Eubanks continued. “Rather the agency has broad discretion to implement other management approaches, including implementation of fertility control to humanely reduce population growth rates and reduction inlivestockgrazing within HMAs.”

Eubanks said that this precedential decision will impact similar pending cases at theNinth Circuit Court of Appealsand inU.S. District Court in Utah, and should serve as a deterrent to other states, including Nevada, consideringlitigationto compel the federal government to round up and remove thousands of wild horses from Westernpublic lands.

The State of Wyoming lawsuit sought the removal of hundreds of wild horses frompublic landsin Wyoming, a state where just 6,500 wild horses remain on 3.2 million acres ofBLM-managed land. By contrast, hundreds of thousands of domestic cattle and sheep graze 18 million acres ofBLMland in the state. Put another way, wild horses are present in Wyoming on just 2 percent of theBLMland grazed by livestock.

Eubanks is also representing the groups on separate litigation involving theBLM’s decision to wipe out wild horses from the Wyoming Checkerboard, a two million acre area of public and private land in the southern part of the state. The groups are awaiting aTenth Circuit decisionon a 2014 lawsuit and have filednew litigationchallenging theBLM’s plan to conduct another Wyoming Checkerboard roundup, beginning as early as October 18.

The American Wild Horse Conservation (formerly American Wild Horse Preservation Campaign) (AWHC) is a coalition of more than 50 horseadvocacy, public interest, and conservation organizations dedicated to preserving the American wild horse in viable, free-roaming herds for generations to come, as part of our national heritage.

The Cloud Foundationis a non-profit organization dedicated to the preservation and protection of wild horses and burros on our Westernpublic landswith a focus on protecting Cloud’s herd in the Pryor Mountains of Montana. Cloud is the subject of Foundation founder Ginger Kathrens' groundbreaking PBS/Nature documentaries.

Return to Freedom(RTF) is a national non-profit dedicated to preserving the freedom, diversity, and habitat of wild horses and burros through sanctuary, education,advocacy, and conservation, and has operated the American Wild Horse Sanctuary in Central Coastal, CA. since 1998.

Carol WalkerandKimerlee Curylare renowned wild horse photographers who regularly photograph the wild horses of the Adobe Town, Great Divide Basin, and Salt Wells Creek HMAs. Walker is also a board member for the Wild Horse Freedom Federation.

Meyer Glitzenstein & Eubanks LLPis a public interest environmental law firm with offices in Washington, D.C. and Fort Collins, Colorado.